A few weeks ago, my friend Owl and I were talking about music, and he brought up Tracy Chapman. I was a little surprised by this, given that I know Owl is not by any stretch what you'd call a touchy-feely PC Socially Conscious type, and said as much. He admitted he didn't remember much of her music, but that a couple of her songs had really grabbed him.
Personally, I've intentionally avoided listening to a lot of that stuff as my patience and tolerance dwindled for passionate yet muddled thinking, abdication of responsibility, insistence that the System, Government or Man should do something, etc.
Tracy Chapman, Suzanne Vega, 10,000 Maniacs -- I must have driven my parents up a fricking tree.
And it's a bit insidious, how the folkies play it. Some songs are flat-out fantastic. Some of the messages are fairly hard to argue with. Unrequited love? Yeah, been there. Man done ya wrong? Come wallow in my slough of despond. Child Abuse Is Bad! So Is Illiteracy! No kiddin'!
But even when I was 17 I remember listening to the line "why are the missiles called peacekeepers when they're aimed to kill" and thinking, "Well, that's marginally clever wordplay, but does anyone really not understand the concept of Enforcing the Peace? Do people really listen to this and turn activist? How 'bout we just call the missiles 'death dispatchers', will that make you happy? Of course not. Now stop it," and hitting the fast forward button.
You can see that at 17 my snark was unrefined and unrestrained -- and that I have not changed much.
But at 17, I also liked some of those songs. And while I knew they were more manipulative than a John Irving novel, I kind of enjoyed the soaring melodies and overwrought lyrics contrived to get people fired up and inspired. I wasn't about to run off and hoist a picket sign, but I was OK with singing along with some of the tunes while driving on the interstate.
I hadn't really listened to the album since then. So I wondered if, at my advanced age, the same things would still make me cringe or sing along.
Turns out I haven't changed VERY much in 22 years.
The album basically breaks down as an almost perfect bell curve: Three great songs, two I find jaw-clenchingly irritating cos of the lyrics and six that fall in the general "well, I probably wouldn't change the station but they range from Eh to Ew."
Unsurprisingly, the ones that hold up are the love songs. "Baby Can I Hold You," "If Not Now..." and "For You" are soulful evocative pieces that get you Right There.
And then there are the baddies. Le sigh.
The first time I heard the first chords of "
Talkin' Bout a Revolution" I thought it had promise. Then she hit the chorus:
Don't you know you better run, run, run, run, run, run, run, run, run, run, run, run, run
Oh I said you better run, run, run, run, run, run, run, run, run, run, run, run, run
And I just burst out laughing. Oh, Tracy. I hope you paid that word time and a half for all the overtime you made it work. Then I listened to the rest of the lyrics and while I suppose my white guilt was supposed to kick in, my white hostility did and I hit the fast forward button every time after that.
It's only gotten worse as I got older.
Don't you know you're talking about a revolution
It sounds like a whisper
Don't you know they're talking about a revolution
It sounds like a whisper
This song came out in 1988. I'm not really sure what revolution she was talking about -- it's not like there was a big change in the political structure; George Bush won the presidency, the Democrats were already in charge of Congress, so whatever she was talking about didn't get much louder than a whisper.
While they're standing in the welfare lines
Crying at the doorsteps of those armies of salvation
Wasting time in unemployment lines
Sitting around waiting for a promotionSee, it's lines like these that piss me off. What the fuck good would a revolution do someone who's getting welfare? What do you think that revolution is gonna do to your gravy train? Ditto unemployment benefits. And hey, maybe if you were busting your ass instead of sitting on it, you'd actually get that promotion.
Poor people gonna rise up
And get their share
Poor people gonna rise up
And take what's theirs
Well, poor people don't have much, taking what's theirs shouldn't be too much of a hassle. But we all know what this really means is they're not going to take what's THEIRS, they're going to take what's MINE and say it's theirs. Good luck with that, kids.
Finally the tables are starting to turn
Talking about a revolution
I can't figure out what sociopolitical/cultural uprising she was referencing here. Again, nothing "turned" the year she wrote that song. But I bet she was really disappointed with those turning tables in 1994.
"Why?" is the second-worst song on the album, with the aforementioned Peacekeeper lyrics.
Why do the babies starve
When there's enough food to feed the world
Hi. Try the class down the hall, Macroeconomics 101.
Why when there're so many of us
Are there people still aloneChoice, man!
Why are the missiles called peace keepers
When they're aimed to kill
Yeeeah, covered this one already.
Why is a woman still not safe
When she's in her home
Cos she doesn't own a gun?
Love is hate
War is peace
No is yes
And we're all free
And this is where I turn the song off, lest my head explode and make a big mess inside my car or on my couch.
The rest of the songs are the big fat middle of the bell curve. "Fast Car" is the song everyone knows by her and it's interesting to me that this would be the next track after the commie Revolution screed, because this one totally halted my knee-jerk "Oh, Shut. Up." reaction. I mean, "Fast Car" is all about busting your ass to do better and get farther, and figuring out -- perhaps belatedly -- that you've got to kick that draggy no-'count man to the curb -- or I guess, to his car, while you wave from the curb -- if you want to get anywhere. Now, I'm probably ignoring the deeper meaning here, which seems to be that attempting improvement is pointless, because even if you do drag yourself up, something will always drag you down. Yeah, fuck that noise. Let me persist in my delusion.
"
Across the Lines" and "
Behind the Wall" are the kinds of obvious causehead songs I was talking about above. Racial strife is bad! Plenty of blame for both sides! Domestic abuse is bad! Police who won't help are baaaaad! Well, duh.
Frankly, if the little black girl and the screaming Wife had scrounged up guns somewhere, these songs would have very different endings. Of course, they'd also probably be sung by
Miranda Lambert.
"Mountains o' Things" starts out as a universally sympathetic middle-class song.
The life I've always wanted
I guess I'll never have
I'll be working for somebody else
Until I'm in my grave
I'll be dreaming of a live of ease
And mountains
Oh mountains o' things
Hey! I'll never own my own business either! And I want stuff!
Sweet lazy life
Champagne and caviar
I hope you'll come and find me
Cause you know who we are
Those who deserve the best in life
And know what money's worth
And those whose sole misfortune
Was having mountains o' nothing at birthWhoops, I guess you weren't singing the suburban middle-class white chick blues after all, were you?
Oh they tell me
There's still time to save my soul
They tell me
Renounce all
Renounce all those material things you gained by
Exploiting other human beings
Soooo ... does this mean all those poor people I see shopping at WalMart have to return those flip-flops and beach towels and whatnot? Or is it only people like me who should be shopping elsewhere?
Consume more than you need
This is the dream
Make you pauper
Or make you queen
I won't die lonely
I'll have it all prearranged
A grave that's deep and wide enough
For me and all my mountains o' things
Well, that's just silly. You should put it in a trust. You never know when you might get resurrected or zombified.
Mostly I feel lonely
Good good people are
Good people are only
My stepping stones
It's gonna take all my mountains o' things
To surround me
Keep all my enemies away
Keep my sadness and loneliness at bay
Hmf. Seems to me if they're amenable to being stepping stones, they can't be THAT good. Unless it is working out OK for them too, in which case, hey! What's the big loss? Faulty argument, Chapman. And if you want to keep enemies at bay, well, again -- guess what! WalMart sells guns!
Finally, "She's Got Her Ticket" and "For My Lover" are the ones that just don't hold up with time. "Ticket" is a nice little anthem encouraging and espousing the idea of dropping out of one's existence in search of a better one. I think I was OK with this at one point -- before I realized that many of the folks who do that end up like the ones hollering for a revolution.
As for "For My Lover" -- assuming I understand this song correctly -- it's basically some chick doing time so her man could get off scot-free. (There isn't really any indication of his guilt or innocence that I could divine.) At 17, yes, yes, I knew that depth of feeling and strength of character and anything-for-you passion. Now? Yeah, not so much. First off, jail? Moi? Srsly? Secondly ... I don't think even my husband is worth taking a fall for -- and the point there is, my husband would never let me take the fall for him. Any guy who would? DEFINITELY not worth it. "Hey, honey, I killed six people, and I'm sure to go to jail. Why don't you tell them YOU did it??" Mmmm, naaah.
I guess this comes off as old and angry and out of touch. Which is fine. Oftentimes I am old and angry and out of touch. But most of the time I like to think of it as smarter, less enabling and ... well, actually, I'm OK with being out of touch. That part suits me fine.